by Tony Carter
Separation proceedings often involve complex financial evaluations, particularly when one or both spouses own professional practices. Valuing these practices accurately is crucial for equitable settlements.

This article explores the unique challenges and methods involved in valuing professional practices, providing practical insights for family law practitioners.

Understanding Professional Practices

Professional practices include medical, legal, accounting, dental, and other specialised services where the business’s success is closely tied to the professional’s skills and reputation. Unlike other types of businesses, these practices often have unique characteristics, such as personal goodwill, that require careful consideration during valuation.

Unique Challenges in Valuing Professional Practices
Personal vs. Enterprise Goodwill:
  • Personal Goodwill: Attributed to the individual professional’s skills, reputation, and relationships with clients or patients. It is often considered a non-transferable asset.
  • Enterprise Goodwill: Linked to the practice’s established brand, systems, and client base, which could be transferred if the practice is sold.
Income Variability

Professional practices may have fluctuating incomes due to factors such as changes in client demand, regulatory impacts, or the professional’s health and availability.

Non-Transferable Licences and Certifications

Many professional practices require specific licences and certifications that cannot be transferred to another individual, complicating the valuation process.

Dependency on the Professional

The value of the practice may be heavily dependent on the ongoing involvement of the professional, making it challenging to separate the business’s value from the individual’s contributions.

Valuation Methods
Income Approach
  • Capitalization of Earnings: This method involves estimating the future earnings of the practice and applying a capitalization rate to determine its present value. It is particularly useful for practices with predictable and stable income streams.
  • Discounted Cash Flow (DCF): This approach involves projecting the practice’s future cash flows and discounting them to their present value using an appropriate discount rate. It requires accurate projections of future income and expenses.
Market Approach

This method involves comparing the practice to similar businesses that have been sold recently. It requires access to reliable data on comparable sales, which can be challenging for specialized practices.

Asset-Based Approach

This method involves calculating the value of the practice’s tangible and intangible assets. It is often used as a secondary method to cross-check values derived from income or market approaches, or when it has already been established from the assessment of the practice that there is no enterprise goodwill.

Examples
Medical Practice Valuation

A medical single practitioner clinic with a significant portion of personal goodwill might be valued primarily based on the professional’s expected future earnings, adjusted for the non-transferability of personal goodwill.  Practically, this is often (but not always) 100% of the goodwill.

Legal Firm Valuation

A small legal firm with multiple partners may have a mix of personal and enterprise goodwill. The valuation might consider the firm’s brand, client relationships, and the potential for income generation independent of any single partner.

Dental Practice Valuation

A dental practice with established client relationships and a consistent income stream might be valued using a capitalization of earnings approach, with adjustments for the owner’s role and potential income fluctuations.

How We Can Help

Valuing professional practices in separation proceedings requires a nuanced approach that considers financial and non-financial factors. Family law practitioners should work closely with experienced business valuation experts to ensure that all relevant aspects are accurately assessed, leading to fair and equitable settlements. No one professional practice is the same as another, and an understanding of the unique challenges and appropriate valuation methods is critical to navigating these complex cases effectively.

If you or your client are going through a separation and a professional practice forms part of the family assets, our business valuation and forensic experts would be pleased to discuss how an expert report may assist.

To get in touch, please contact our Business Valuation Specialist, Tony Carter, below or on 02 4969 6600.

  • Hidden
    DD slash MM slash YYYY
  • Hidden
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.